상세 보기
Implementing a Cognitively Grounded Artificial Moral Advisor: A Multi-LLM Multi-Agent Approach Based on the Cognitive–Reflective Equilibration Model
- Kim, Chulmin;
- Ahn, Seongjin
WEB OF SCIENCE
0SCOPUS
0초록
Large language model (LLM)-based artificial intelligence is increasingly used in ethically consequential human decision-making, yet fully autonomous machine ethics remains unrealistic, motivating architectures that support rather than replace human ethical judgment. This study introduces the Cognitive–Reflective Equilibration Architecture (CREA), a cognitively grounded artificial moral advisor that operationalizes the Cognitive–Reflective Equilibration Model (CREM), in which reflective reasoning guides ethical judgment from intuitive cognition toward a more advanced equilibrium among competing values, drawing on Piaget and Rawls. CREA implements CREM’s 20-step process through four stage-aligned reasoning agents—Cognitive, Reflective, Equilibration, and Evaluation—coordinated via multi-LLM orchestration, in which auxiliary models independently explore principles, generate counterarguments, and score supporting and opposing considerations to externalize reflective deliberation. The architecture was empirically evaluated by comparing four configurations—single-agent, multi-agent, multi-LLM, and multi-LLM with knowledge- and reasoning-bank augmentation—across four indicators of advice quality using 500 matched execution units per configuration. All comparisons are system-internal: advice quality was scored by CREA’s own multi-LLM measurement pipeline rather than by human ethicists, so the findings reflect relative differences among architectures under LLM-based self-evaluation, not normative validity. Within that scope, distributing reflective reasoning across multiple models was associated with higher reason-giving (justifiability) and normative-alignment scores relative to simpler configurations. CREA therefore offers an empirically characterized, auditable advisor architecture whose potential to scaffold human ethical judgment remains a hypothesis for user-centered validation rather than a demonstrated outcome. © 2026 by the authors.
키워드
- 제목
- Implementing a Cognitively Grounded Artificial Moral Advisor: A Multi-LLM Multi-Agent Approach Based on the Cognitive–Reflective Equilibration Model
- 저자
- Kim, Chulmin; Ahn, Seongjin
- 발행일
- 2026-09-02
- 유형
- Article
- 권
- 14
- 호
- 9
- 언어
- ENG
- 출판사
- Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI)
- 발행국가
- 스위스
- ISSN
- E 2079-3200
P 2079-3200