Guidelines for Theory Selection: The IMPACT Framework
  • Hollebeek, Linda D.
  • Kumar, V.
  • Srivastava, Rajendra K.
  • Lim, Weng Marc
  • Urbonavicius, Sigitas
Citations

WEB OF SCIENCE

36
Citations

SCOPUS

34

초록

Though the role of adopting an appropriate theory in shaping the publishability and impact of research has long been recognized, psychology and marketing researchers lack specific guidance on how to choose a theory to frame their work. Addressing this gap in the literature, this article proposes a set of guidelines for the selection of relevant macro-foundational theory to guide research projects addressing specific meso- or micro-foundational theoretical entities (e.g., constructs or individual decision-making) for research impact. Specifically, we develop a set of six guidelines to select an appropriate macro-foundational theory for research impact, including Interestingness, Matching, Parsimony, Applicability, Conceptual rigor, and Testability (collectively abbreviated as the “IMPACT” guidelines). We next depict the proposed guidelines in an organizing framework that specifies Matching, the theoretical co-infusion of the studied micro- or meso-foundational theoretical entity and the chosen macro-foundational theory, as the central action item for researchers to shape the impact of their work. Researchers are then advised to use the five remaining guidelines to assess the quality of their proposed Matching for research impact. We conclude by discussing pertinent implications that arise from our analyses (e.g., to ensure Interestingness, we recommend researchers to select a macro-foundational theory that refutes (vs. affirms) prior findings). © 2025 The Author(s). Psychology & Marketing published by Wiley Periodicals LLC.

키워드

macro-foundational theorymarketingmeso-foundational theorymicro-foundational theorypsychologyresearch impacttheorytheory selectionIMPORTANT MARKETING ISSUESCUSTOMER ENGAGEMENTEMPIRICAL GENERALIZATIONSSCALE DEVELOPMENTRESEARCH CENTERSBEHAVIORSCIENCERIGORDISCIPLINESPARSIMONY
제목
Guidelines for Theory Selection: The IMPACT Framework
저자
Hollebeek, Linda D.Kumar, V.Srivastava, Rajendra K.Lim, Weng MarcUrbonavicius, Sigitas
DOI
10.1002/mar.70009
발행일
2025-11
유형
Article; Early Access
저널명
Psychology and Marketing
42
11
페이지
2789 ~ 2806